An Unreasonable Conclusion

Posted by: Bob Quinn on July 20, 2010 at 4:21 pm

The FCC’s conclusion that broadband is not being reasonably deployed in the U.S., on a national basis, based upon 7 million homes in rural America that would require $23.5 billion in federal subsidies to connect to wireline broadband, is an unreasonable conclusion.  Here is why.

As a part of its National Broadband Plan, the FCC identified 7 million homes without access to wireline broadband service capable of 4 Mbps.  Some of those areas have broadband at lower speeds; all have access to satellite-based broadband. The agency concluded “it is unlikely that private capital will fund infrastructure capable of delivering broadband that meets the [4 Mbps] target” because of the exorbitant cost of reaching those homes. As we heard again last week, some of those areas today receive thousands of dollars annually per line to support the provision of voice service.

To the extent that this report provides momentum to finally fix the long-broken universal service/intercarrier compensation problem, and to remove actual economic barriers to broadband investment, then that is a positive development.  However, to the extent it is used as pretext to justify more investment choking regulation a la the Title II debate, we will have squandered another opportunity to address the real broadband issues in this country.

Comments (1)

Well said, Bob. Ginning up a nonexistent crisis is a ploy commonly used to justify rash or unwise actions – in this case, unnecessary regulation and an unwarranted, most likely illegal power grab.

Brett Glass July 20, 2010 at 6:21 pm

Write a Comment

* Required

 characters available


AT&T pre-moderates comments on our blog before they are published. This means there will be a delay between the time a comment is submitted and it appears on the post. Profanity, or topics that are not germane to the post will not be approved for posting. If you wish to communicate with AT&T regarding customer service you may do so via phone at 1-800-331-0500. We are also available on Twitter at @ATTCares.